Aylwin: Barrie’s Enforcement-First Approach Is Failing Homeless — Housing, Not Policing, Is Solution

The housing and homelessness crisis in Simcoe County has reached a critical point, raising urgent questions about policy, support, and community responsibility.

Keenan Aylwin, former Barrie City Councillor and current social worker, spoke to civic journalist Christine Nayler about the scale of the problem. He highlighted that up to 100 people living outdoors without proper shelter, sanitation, or basic support demonstrates that current policies are failing the most vulnerable. According to Aylwin, this humanitarian crisis is not a natural occurrence but the result of policy decisions that have consistently underfunded and underprioritized adequate housing solutions. In his view, the only real path forward is the creation of social and supportive housing that addresses both shelter and the services residents need to thrive.

The issue has become painfully visible following the brutal killing of two residents at the Flat Rock encampment near Victoria Street. The city officially cited environmental and public safety concerns as reasons for the encampment’s closure. Yet, for the residents, this action has meant displacement, fractured communities, and the sudden loss of a space where informal support networks existed. Aylwin emphasized that while safety is important, closing encampments without providing viable housing solutions only deepens vulnerability.

He also expressed concern about the response of Mayor Alex Nuttall. Aylwin believes that the mayor is using the tragedy to justify a zero-encampment policy without offering any tangible path to stable housing. He warns that focusing primarily on enforcement rather than on the root causes of homelessness pushes people further to the margins, increasing both isolation and risk.

Simcoe Community Media is actively speaking with encampment residents, community members, advocates, and housing experts to understand the full scope of the crisis. These conversations aim to explore how this situation developed, whether it could have been prevented, and what changes are necessary to ensure future tragedies are avoided.

This is a story about people—about lives disrupted, communities fractured, and a system that continues to fall short. It is also a story about the urgent need for collective action, accountability, and a shift in priorities toward housing and support rather than punitive measures. Residents, advocates, and civic leaders alike must confront the reality that homelessness is not simply a matter of law enforcement, but a reflection of deeper systemic failures.

We will continue to listen, report, and elevate these voices, ensuring that the human cost of policy inaction is not ignored. The lives affected demand attention, empathy, and action from the entire community.