Petition to Remove Toronto's Allan Gardens Encampment

By 

Gabriel Meissner - a Youth Journalist at Focus Media Arts Centre

A recent petition submitted to Change.org by the Allan Gardens Neighbourhood Group has ignited a passionate discussion surrounding the encampments in Allan Gardens Park, situated at the intersection of Sherbourne and Gerrard Streets in Toronto. The petition urges the city of Toronto to take action and remove the encampments, citing safety concerns and the park's diminishing usability. With approximately 36 encampments as of April 2023, accounting for about half of all encampments in the city, tensions have escalated, prompting residents to voice their concerns.

The petition highlights the rising number of unhoused individuals living in Allan Gardens Park, in violation of Toronto City Bylaw 608, which prohibits camping on public parkland. Despite the city's provision of services such as policing, public health support, garbage cleanup, toilet facilities, and assistance with housing applications, the situation has not improved. The encampments persist and are now causing fear, stress, and anguish among residents.

Tragically, incidents of violence have occurred in the park, including a murder and a stabbing. The presence of garbage, drug paraphernalia, human feces, and open fires further intensifies concerns. Some residents feel threatened, having experienced verbal attacks, and are constantly living under the shadow of potential violence, impeding their ability to enjoy the park. The heightened risks faced by vulnerable groups such as children and seniors are particularly distressing to many.

Councillor Chris Moise of Ward 13 has been diligently working to reduce the number of tents in the park. Through offering individualized housing solutions, he successfully decreased the encampments to a mere seven at one point. However, these remaining encampments are occupied by hard-core 'land-back' activists who show no inclination towards compromise or accepting housing offers. Their presence has acted as a catalyst for the exponential growth of encampments in Allan Gardens, again.

The petition calls for fellow city councillors' support in restoring safety and the rule of law to the neighborhood. While the city supports the "housing first approach" initiative, as seen in Dufferin Grove Park, it also emphasizes the importance of respecting the Superior Court ruling and city bylaws. The petition argues that allowing activists to obstruct the park's restoration as a usable green space for all citizens, particularly marginalized groups, contradicts the principles of fairness and inclusivity.

The petition has gained momentum, with ordinary individuals expressing their support by signing it. Currently, with 1,060 signatures, the goal of reaching 1,500 seems within reach. Signatories voice their frustration with the encampments, asserting that hardworking taxpayers deserve the right to enjoy their parks without fear. Some individuals even question their obligation to pay taxes if the city fails to enforce its own laws.

Recognizing the significance of the issue and the widespread interest in finding a resolution that ensures safety and inclusivity for all park users, the Regent Park TV team visited Allan Gardens to gather perspectives from the community. This initiative highlights the community's commitment to addressing the issue and finding a sustainable solution.

The petition submitted by the Allan Gardens Neighbourhood Group has brought attention to the encampments in Allan Gardens Park and the challenges faced by both residents and the city. Balancing the need for compassionate solutions to homelessness with the concerns of safety and park usability presents a complex issue for Toronto. It is crucial for the city and its representatives to collaborate in finding a sustainable and equitable resolution. This involves addressing the immediate safety concerns while simultaneously tackling the root causes of homelessness and providing suitable housing options for those in need.